34 MLB Players who won Comeback Player of the Year
| # | Player | Year | League | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Cody Bellinger | 2023 | NL | |
| 2. | Lance Berkman | 2011 | NL | |
| 3. | Chris Carpenter | 2009 | NL | |
| 4. | Carlos Carrasco | 2019 | AL | |
| 5. | Josh Donaldson | 2019 | NL | |
| 6. | Jacoby Ellsbury | 2011 | AL | |
| 7. | Prince Fielder | 2015 | AL | |
| 8. | Nomar Garciaparra | 2006 | NL | |
| 9. | Jason Giambi | 2005 | AL | |
| 10. | Ken Griffey | 2005 | NL | |
| 11. | Matt Harvey | 2015 | NL | |
| 12. | Liam Hendriks | 2023 | AL | |
| 13. | Aaron Hill | 2009 | AL | |
| 14. | Tim Hudson | 2010 | NL | |
| 15. | Jim Johnson | 2006 | AL | |
| 16. | Cliff Lee | 2008 | AL | |
| 17. | Brad Lidge | 2008 | NL | |
| 18. | Francisco Liriano | 2013 | NL | |
| 19. | Francisco Liriano | 2010 | AL | |
| 20. | Casey McGehee | 2014 | NL | |
| 21. | Mike Moustakas | 2017 | AL | |
| 22. | Carlos Pena | 2007 | AL | |
| 23. | Rick Porcello | 2016 | AL | |
| 24. | Buster Posey | 2012 | NL | |
| 25. | David Price | 2018 | AL | |
| 26. | Albert Pujols | 2022 | NL | |
| 27. | Anthony Rendon | 2016 | NL | |
| 28. | Mariano Rivera | 2013 | AL | |
| 29. | Fernando Rodney | 2012 | AL | |
| 30. | Jonny Venters | 2018 | NL | |
| 31. | Justin Verlander | 2022 | AL | |
| 32. | Chris Young | 2014 | AL | |
| 33. | Dmitri Young | 2007 | NL | |
| 34. | Ryan Zimmerman | 2017 | NL |
Barry Codell's Official Blog |
| The Daily Diamond