| Year | Voted By | Ballots | Votes Needed | Total Votes | Vote % = Total Votes÷Votes Needed | Inducted | Inducted For | | 2001 | BBWAA | 515 | 387 | 145 | % | No | Player | | 2002 | BBWAA | 472 | 354 | 96 | % | No | Player | | 2003 | BBWAA | 496 | 372 | 68 | % | No | Player | | 2004 | BBWAA | 506 | 380 | 65 | % | No | Player | | 2005 | BBWAA | 516 | 387 | 59 | % | No | Player | | 2006 | BBWAA | 520 | 390 | 64 | % | No | Player | | 2007 | BBWAA | 545 | 409 | 54 | % | No | Player | | 2008 | BBWAA | 543 | 408 | 86 | % | No | Player | | 2009 | BBWAA | 539 | 405 | 64 | % | No | Player | | 2010 | BBWAA | 539 | 405 | 87 | % | No | Player | | 2011 | BBWAA | 581 | 436 | 79 | % | No | Player | | 2012 | BBWAA | 573 | 430 | 102 | % | No | Player | | 2013 | BBWAA | 569 | 427 | 75 | % | No | Player | | 2014 | BBWAA | 571 | 429 | 47 | % | No | Player | | 2015 | BBWAA | 549 | 412 | 50 | % | No | Player | | 2023 | Contemporary Era | 16 | 12 | 8 | % | No | Player |
|
| The Daily Diamond